For reviewers

Suggested structure of reviews to be submitted to the "Ukrainian Geographical Journal" DOWNLOAD .docx

Editorial Board of the "Ukrainian Geographic Journal"
Institute of Geography NAS of Ukraine
44, Volodymyrska str., Kyiv, 01054
E-mail: [email protected]

Review
Author / authors  
Title of paper reviewed  
Relevance of research topic  
Clearness of the research goal  
Does the paper’s  structure correspond with the requirements for scientific publications and recommendations to the UGJ’s authors? See "For authors"  
Does the content correspond with the structure:

  • Summary
  • Analysis of previous research
  • Research methods
  • Obtained results of the study
  • Conclusions
  • Original contribution to the selected research field (clear novelty). The scientific and practical significance of the research carried out.
  
Availability of tables, pictures, maps  
Availability and appropriateness of bibliographic data  
Main comments of the reviewer  
Is paper fit for publishing in UGJ?  

 

Reviewer